Oftentimes, a film based in reality will include a handful of fabricated details and interactions. Many people dedicate themselves to pointing out instances where true stories deviate from the truth. Such films and television shows are consistently challenged with intertwining fact and fiction.
But if something claims to be a true story, why can it get away with including details that aren’t entirely true?
Narrative films are not documentaries. Even documentaries often distort reality to serve their intended narrative, to a degree. To say that fact should always trump fiction in filmmaking (fiction being any sort of dramatization, modification, or distortion of events or situations) is to ignore the purpose of the craft: to tell a compelling story.
The most important part of any screenplay is the story. The screenwriter‘s ultimate responsibility is to ensure that all other components service the story. Oftentimes, complete factual accuracy is sacrificed for the good of the story.
With that said, factual accuracy shouldn’t necessarily be thrown out the window entirely. Believability, as well as faithfulness to the source, matters greatly. At times, it’s best to hang on to some facts because their truth is in itself compelling and entertaining in a way that no fictional component could match. Finding the right balance between fact and fiction is the key to telling a truthful story.
Table of Contents
“Based on a True Story” vs “Inspired by a True Story”
A title card at the beginning of a movie with any historical basis will likely either read “based on a true story” or “inspired by a true story.” There are other variations, but these two are the most common.
One should consider the subtle distinction between these two claims prior to diving into the screenwriting process. The language, though vague, makes a difference in deciding how to balance fact and fiction.
“Based On”
Any film that claims to be “based on a true story” will likely stick more closely to the true events. Inevitably, the filmmakers will take some creative liberties, but those will likely be fewer and further between.
“Inspired By”
The true events that inspired these films are used only as a basis for the story you are seeing. The filmmakers may draw from real events and people, but they will fashion the story more to their desired message. Greater dramatic license will be taken, sometimes because the real events are not quite compelling enough on their own.
Among the other variations from these examples include films that depict true events or take place in the midst of them. Such a film usually doesn’t make any sort of claim regarding historical accuracy because the story itself revolves around entirely fictionalized characters.
Take James Cameron’s Titanic, for example.
- The main characters around whom the story revolves were not real people.
- Yet their surroundings are deeply researched and very accurate, and many of the people they interact with are drawn from real people too.
- With a factually based backdrop, the fictionality of the characters ceases to matter to an audience.
Zero Dark Thirty boasts the lengthier disclaimer of “based on firsthand accounts of actual events”.
- The plurality of this statement indicates that multiple perspectives have informed this narrative.
- The film, therefore, seems to claim both a high level of authority and an ambiguity of perspective.
Members only
This article continues in our Members Area
Join SCREENWRITING: EVOLVED for full access to 700+ guides, whitepapers, the script library, industry interviews and much more.
Join SCREENWRITING: EVOLVED — just $9.99/monthCancel any time · No commitment
Not ready to join yet?
Comments are closed.